Car comparison

BMW X1 (E84) 28ivsBMW X1 (U11) 23d

Compare specs, acceleration, fuel consumption, dimensions, practicality, and estimated running costs side by side.

New comparison

BMW X1 (E84)

28i

245 hp1997 ccGasolineAWDAutomaticTurbochargedSUV2011-2012
VS

BMW X1 (U11)

23d

197 hp1995 ccDieselAWDAutomaticTurbocharged2022-present

Comparison overview

Use the estimates as comparison hints and verify exact figures before making decisions.

Best choices

BMW X1 (E84) 28i

  • Quickest 0-100 km/h
    6.5 s
  • Fastest top speed
    240 km/h
    149 mph
  • Most powerful
    245 hp
    183 kW
  • Lightest
    1,595 kg
    3,516 lb
  • Best power-to-weight
    154 hp/t
    115 kW/t
    6.5 kg/hp
  • Best overall score
    64/100
  • Best performance score
    57/100
  • Best practicality score
    80/100

BMW X1 (U11) 23d

  • Highest torque
    400 Nm
    295 lb-ft
  • Lowest combined fuel consumption
    5.3 L/100 km
    44.4 mpg US
    53.3 mpg UK
  • Best estimated range
    849 km
    528 mi
  • Largest trunk
    500 L
  • Best economy score
    93/100

Specification comparison

Specification comparison
ModelBMWX1 (E84)28iBMWX1 (U11)23d
Power
245hp183kW
197hp147kW
Torque
350Nm258lb-ft
400Nm295lb-ft
Curb weight
1,595kg3,516lb
1,690kg3,726lb
Gross weight
2,150kg4,740lb
2,265kg4,993lb
Top speed
240 km/h
149 mph
225 km/h
140 mph
To 99% top speed
72.7s99% target: 238 km/h / 148 mph
Calculated
90.1s99% target: 223 km/h / 138 mph
Calculated
0-100 km/h
6.5s
7.4s
0-200 km/h
25.1s
Calculated
36.7s
Calculated
0-60 mph
6.2s
Calculated
7.0s
Calculated
Fuel consumption
7.9L/100 km29.8mpg US35.8mpg UK
5.3L/100 km44.4mpg US53.3mpg UK
Fuel consumption city
10.4L/100 km22.6mpg US27.2mpg UK
-
Fuel consumption highway
6.4L/100 km36.8mpg US44.1mpg UK
-
Quarter mile
14.5s
Calculated
15.4s
Calculated
Power-to-weight
154hp/t115kW/t70hp/1000 lb
Calculated
117hp/t87kW/t53hp/1000 lb
Calculated
Torque-to-weight
219Nm/t147lb-ft/ton
Calculated
237Nm/t158lb-ft/ton
Calculated
Estimated range
797km496mi
Calculated
849km528mi
Calculated
Displacement
1,997cc122cu in
1,995cc122cu in
Length
4,454mm175in
4,500mm177in
Width
1,798mm71in
1,845mm73in
Height
1,545mm61in
1,642mm65in
Wheelbase
2,760mm109in
2,692mm106in
Front track
1,500mm59in
1,592mm63in
Rear track
1,529mm60in
1,593mm63in
Ground clearance
194mm8in
205mm8in
Trunk volume
420L
500L
Max trunk volume
1,350L
1,545L
Doors
5
5
Seats
5
5
Fuel tank
63L
45L

Performance charts

Use the estimates as comparison hints and verify exact figures before making decisions.

Dyno simulation

Estimated stock-style power and torque curves by engine speed.

BMW X1 (E84) 28iBMW X1 (U11) 23dPowerTorque
  • BMW X1 (E84) 28i: Power / Torque
  • BMW X1 (U11) 23d: Power / Torque
Dyno simulation data table
VehiclePeak power RPMPeak torque RPMMax engine speed
BMWX1 (E84)28i5,000-6,500 rpm1,250-4,800 rpm6,750 rpm
BMWX1 (U11)23d4,000 rpm1,500-2,750 rpm4,250 rpm

Acceleration curve

Estimated speed over time for selected vehicles.

Acceleration and drag-race table
MetricBMWX1 (E84)28iBMWX1 (U11)23d
Acceleration checkpoints
0-60 mph
0-97 km/h
6.2 s
7.0 s
0-100 km/h
0-62 mph
6.5 s
7.4 s
0-200 km/h
0-124 mph
25.1 s
36.7 s
Top speed
240 km/h
149 mph
225 km/h
140 mph
Drag race simulation
60 ft
18 m
2.5 s
2.4 s
330 ft
101 m
6.4 s
6.6 s
1/8 mile
201 m
9.6 s
10.0 s
1000 ft
305 m
12.3 s
12.9 s
1/4 mile
402 m
14.5 s
15.4 s
Trap speed
1/4 mile
402 m
160 km/h
100 mph
148 km/h
92 mph

Power comparison

Bar comparison chart for Power. Higher is better · hp / kW

Chart data table
VehicleValue
BMWX1 (E84)28i
245 hp
183 kW
BMWX1 (U11)23d
197 hp
147 kW

BMW X1 (E84) 28i has 48 hp more than BMW X1 (U11) 23d.

The biggest power difference is between BMW X1 (U11) 23d and BMW X1 (E84) 28i: 48 hp (36 kW).

Torque comparison

Bar comparison chart for Torque. Higher is better · Nm / lb-ft

Chart data table
VehicleValue
BMWX1 (E84)28i
350 Nm
258 lb-ft
BMWX1 (U11)23d
400 Nm
295 lb-ft

Curb weight comparison

Bar comparison chart for Curb weight. Lower is better · kg / lb

Chart data table
VehicleValue
BMWX1 (E84)28i
1,595 kg
3,516 lb
BMWX1 (U11)23d
1,690 kg
3,726 lb

Top speed without limiter comparison

Bar comparison chart for Top speed without limiter. Higher is better · km/h / mph

Chart data table
VehicleValue
BMWX1 (E84)28i
240 km/h
149 mph
BMWX1 (U11)23d
225 km/h
140 mph

0-100 km/h comparison

Bar comparison chart for 0-100 km/h. Lower is better · seconds

Chart data table
VehicleValue
BMWX1 (E84)28i6.5 s
BMWX1 (U11)23d7.4 s

The biggest 0-100 km/h difference is between BMW X1 (E84) 28i and BMW X1 (U11) 23d: 0.9 s.

Fuel consumption comparison

Bar comparison chart for Fuel consumption. Lower is better · L/100 km / mpg US / mpg UK

Chart data table
VehicleValue
BMWX1 (E84)28i
7.9 L/100 km
29.8 mpg US
35.8 mpg UK
BMWX1 (U11)23d
5.3 L/100 km
44.4 mpg US
53.3 mpg UK

The biggest fuel consumption difference is between BMW X1 (U11) 23d and BMW X1 (E84) 28i: 2.6 L/100 km.

Power-to-weight comparison

Bar comparison chart for Power-to-weight. Higher is better · hp/t / kW/t

Chart data table
VehicleValue
BMWX1 (E84)28i
154 hp/t
115 kW/t
6.5 kg/hp
BMWX1 (U11)23d
117 hp/t
87 kW/t
8.6 kg/hp

Estimated range comparison

Bar comparison chart for Estimated range. Higher is better · km / mi

Chart data table
VehicleValue
BMWX1 (E84)28i
797 km
496 mi
BMWX1 (U11)23d
849 km
528 mi

Performance spider chart

Radar chart comparing normalized performance and fuel-consumption scores.

Chart data table
VehiclePowerAccelerationTop speed
BMWX1 (E84)28i
245 hp
183 kW
6.5 s
240 km/h
149 mph
BMWX1 (U11)23d
197 hp
147 kW
7.4 s
225 km/h
140 mph

Most attractive quadrant

Scatter chart with performance score on the X axis and practicality score on the Y axis.

Chart data table
VehiclePerformance scorePracticality score
BMWX1 (E84)28i
Power
245 hp
183 kW
0-100 km/h6.5 s
Top speed
240 km/h
149 mph
Doors/seats
5 doors
5 seats
Trunk
420 L
14.8 cu ft
Length
4,454 mm
175.4 in
Height
1,545 mm
60.8 in
BMWX1 (U11)23d
Power
197 hp
147 kW
0-100 km/h7.4 s
Top speed
225 km/h
140 mph
Doors/seats
5 doors
5 seats
Trunk
500 L
17.7 cu ft
Length
4,500 mm
177.2 in
Height
1,642 mm
64.6 in

Performance vs fuel economy

Cars closer to the top-right corner combine stronger performance with better fuel economy scores.

Performance vs fuel economy data table
VehiclePerformance scoreFuel economy score
BMWX1 (E84)28i
Power
245 hp
183 kW
0-100 km/h6.5 s
Top speed
240 km/h
149 mph
7.9 L/100 km
29.8 mpg US
35.8 mpg UK
BMWX1 (U11)23d
Power
197 hp
147 kW
0-100 km/h7.4 s
Top speed
225 km/h
140 mph
5.3 L/100 km
44.4 mpg US
53.3 mpg UK

BMW X1 (E84) 28i is closest to the top-right balance target for performance and fuel economy.

Acceleration vs fuel consumption

Cars closer to the lower-left corner offer a better mix of quick acceleration and low fuel consumption.

Acceleration vs fuel consumption data table
VehicleFuel consumption, L/100 km0-100 km/h, s
BMWX1 (E84)28i
7.9 L/100 km
29.8 mpg US
35.8 mpg UK
6.5 s
BMWX1 (U11)23d
5.3 L/100 km
44.4 mpg US
53.3 mpg UK
7.4 s

Power-to-weight vs fuel consumption

The shaded area favors higher power-to-weight with lower combined fuel consumption.

Power-to-weight vs fuel consumption data table
VehiclePower-to-weight, hp/tFuel consumption, L/100 km
BMWX1 (E84)28i
154 hp/t
115 kW/t
6.5 kg/hp
7.9 L/100 km
29.8 mpg US
35.8 mpg UK
BMWX1 (U11)23d
117 hp/t
87 kW/t
8.6 kg/hp
5.3 L/100 km
44.4 mpg US
53.3 mpg UK

Detailed score breakdown

Detailed score breakdown
VehicleBMWX1 (E84)28iBMWX1 (U11)23d
Power
245 hp
183 kW
197 hp
147 kW
Torque
350 Nm
258 lb-ft
400 Nm
295 lb-ft
Acceleration
6.5 s
7.4 s
Top speed
240 km/h
149 mph
225 km/h
140 mph
Lightness
1,595 kg
3,516 lb
1,690 kg
3,726 lb
Fuel consumption
7.9 L/100 km
29.8 mpg US
35.8 mpg UK
5.3 L/100 km
44.4 mpg US
53.3 mpg UK
Practicality
Doors/seats
5 doors
5 seats
Trunk
420 L
14.8 cu ft
Length
4,454 mm
175.4 in
Height
1,545 mm
60.8 in
Doors/seats
5 doors
5 seats
Trunk
500 L
17.7 cu ft
Length
4,500 mm
177.2 in
Height
1,642 mm
64.6 in
Range score
797 km
496 mi
849 km
528 mi
Trunk score
420 L
14.8 cu ft
500 L
17.7 cu ft
Power-to-weight score
154 hp/t
115 kW/t
6.5 kg/hp
117 hp/t
87 kW/t
8.6 kg/hp
Overall
Fixed score
Fixed score

Fuel cost and annual usage

Estimate running costs from combined consumption, your annual distance, and the fuel price in your local currency.

Enter the fuel price in your local currency, for example €/L, $/gal, £/L or any other local currency.

LC = Local Currency

Fuel cost and annual usage
VehicleBMW X1 (E84) 28iBMW X1 (U11) 23d
Consumption7.9 L/100 km29.8 mpg US35.8 mpg UK5.3 L/100 km44.4 mpg US53.3 mpg UK
Cost / 100 km13.83 LC100 km9.28 LC100 km
Cost / 100 mi22.25 LC100 mi14.93 LC100 mi
Annual fuel used1,185 L313 US gal261 UK gal795 L210 US gal175 UK gal
Annual fuel cost2,074 LC/year1,391 LC/year

Head-to-head comparisons

BMW X1 (E84) 28i

  • Has 48 hp more
  • Is 95 kg lighter
  • Is 0.9 s quicker from 0-100 km/h
  • Has 15 km/h (9 mph) higher top speed
  • Has 37 hp/t better power-to-weight

Pros

  • Quickest 0-100 km/h in this comparison
  • Highest top speed
  • Most powerful
  • Lightest
  • Best power-to-weight ratio

Cons

  • Highest combined fuel consumption
  • Smallest trunk

BMW X1 (U11) 23d

  • Has 50 Nm more
  • Uses 2.6 L/100 km less fuel
  • Has 52 km (32 mi) more estimated range
  • Has 80 L more trunk volume

Pros

  • Highest torque
  • Lowest combined fuel consumption
  • Best estimated range
  • Largest trunk

Cons

  • Slowest 0-100 km/h
  • Lowest power
  • Heaviest
  • Lowest top speed

Choose cars to compare

Brand
Model
Generation
Engine or modification
BMW X1 (E84) 28i
BMW X1 (U11) 23d
Compare selected cars
2 vehicles selected

Popular comparisons

28i
28i
VS
BMWX1 (E84)28ivsBMWX1 (E84 LCI)Facelift 201228i
23d
20i
VS
BMWX1 (U11)23dvsBMWX1 (F48)20i
28i
23i
VS
BMWX1 (E84)28ivsBMWX1 (U11)23i
23d
23d
VS
BMWX1 (U11)23dvsBMWX1 (E84)23d
28i
28i
VS
BMWX1 (E84)28ivsBMWX3 (F25)28i
23d
223d
VS
BMWX1 (U11)23dvsBMW2 Series Active Tourer (U06)223d
28i
28i
VS
BMWX1 (E84)28ivsBMWX3 (F25 LCI)Facelift 201428i
23d
320d
VS
BMWX1 (U11)23dvsBMW3 Series Sedan (G20 LCI)Facelift 2022320d
28i
40d
VS
BMWX1 (E84)28ivsBMWX5 (E70 LCI)Facelift 201040d
23d
220d
VS
BMWX1 (U11)23dvsBMW2 Series Gran Coupe (F44)220d
28i
35i
VS
BMWX1 (E84)28ivsBMWX6 (E71)35i
23d
420d
VS
BMWX1 (U11)23dvsBMW4 Series Coupe (G22)420d
BMW X1 (E84) 28i vs BMW X1 (U11) 23d - car comparison - FastVsFaster